Friday's 13 - Taylor Swift is About to Enter Her Voodoo Lounge Era
Whether she likes it or not - and she probably won’t, Taylor Swift will soon enter into a phase of her career that all music superstars inevitably reach - she is becoming a legacy artist.
There comes a point in every big artist‘s career where their fans like them for what they have already done and not for what they will do in the future. Sure, true fans will test out any new material but it will not have the lasting impact that previous albums and songs do. Given the tepid response to the four new songs she recently put out earlier this fall and her status as a happily married newlywed, I think it is fair to conclude she will be entering that phase of her career in 2027.
The closest analogy I could think of was The Rolling Stones, hence the title of this article. Taylor Swift and The Rolling Stones are two of the biggest stadium acts ever. Tattoo You (but probably Some Girls) was the last essential album Mick, Keith, and crew put out. When they released Steel Wheels in the late 1980's and Voodoo Lounge in the mid-1990's it was to big fanfare and accompanied by massive stadium tours, but the albums did not have the staying power nor contained any classic songs that their 1960's and 1970's output did. Regardless of the merits of any of their later period songs, it is inarguable that none of those songs have broken into the top tier of Rolling Stones greatest hits
That is the prediction for Taylor next year - a big announcement of both a new album and accompanying tour. Any tours she embarks on going forward will be massive endeavors as long as she commits to touring much in the same way The Rolling Stones have for the past few decades. Those tours will also have to be 90% old hits and 10% new stuff to merit the stadiums, prices, and not alienating the fanbase.
The later Stones albums received positive reviews and have decent tracks you may remember - Mixed Emotions, You Got Me Rocking, Saint of Me and Anybody Seen My Baby, but I doubt most Stones fans are going to give Bridges to Babylon a listen when Exile on Main Street and Sticky Fingers exist.
One of the tricky parts of this inevitable outcome is figuring out when it will happen. Bear in mind it will happen - it always does, but only on a look back can you pinpoint where and when that occurred. A few examples:
Tom Petty. Into the Great Wide Open was the last classic Tom Petty and/or the Heartbreakers album. The Last DJ and Mojo received critical acclaim, but no songs from those albums penetrated the core setlist that would highlight a Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers concert. Tom Petty, maybe more than any artist, knew how to incorporate new material into an arena show - open with 5 stone cold classics, sprinkle in 2-3 songs off the new album mid-show, watch those songs become "bathroom songs" when everyone rushes out for a bathroom break and another drink, ready to enjoy the last hour of more classics, and close with another 10-12 of your greatest hits.
Foo Fighters. Wasting Light is probably the best Foo Fighters album start to finish and it contains the fewest filler tracks, even though their best singles/songs are from their earlier albums. From Sonic Highways and Concrete and Gold and beyond, they have not been able to put out a song that can consistently be a highlight of their 3 hour shows the way their earlier songs can.
Billy Joel. Billy Joel was a rare artist who seemingly knew this was inevitable. In the 1990's he made the conscious decision to stop releasing new albums and material after River of Dreams. He willingly settled into legacy artist mode with his sweetheart Madison Square Garden monthly residency that lasted for over a decade.
Garth Brooks. Country music, where Taylor started, is more of a singles driven genre (at least when it comes to popular country music) so there are not too many analogies here. Garth Brooks probably settled into legacy artist mode around Fresh Horses and Sevens, with not much of his - albeit limited - output after that making it into his canon. Checking the setlists from his 2026 shows confirms this. I also vaguely recall an old interview with Garth that used to air on CMT where he acknowledged that this inevitably happens to all artists at some point in their career.
George Strait. Similar to Garth, George Strait also became a legacy artist at some point in the late 1990's or early 2000's. He had a few classic albums - Ocean Front Property and the Pure Country soundtrack chief among them, but he relied on a single or two with his later albums, which seemingly came out like clockwork once a year. He was also aided by the fact that he was a megastar who didn't write most of his songs and therefore had the pick of the crop from the top songwriters on Music Row who would kill to get a track on a George Strait record and the accompanying royalties.
Shania Twain. Shania had a shorter peak but a peak nonetheless that rivaled Taylor's, but she is not a great analogy given her top output was tied to her producer and then-husband Mutt Lange. Mutt Lange applied his AC/DC and Def Leppard studio wizardry to help Shania put out three massive albums. Her post-Mutt Lange limited output cannot rival those three albums - The Woman In Me, Come on Over and Up!. I am not even sure I can name a song after those albums.
Madonna. Madonna at her peak was at a cultural level equivalent to Taylor Swift at hers. Ray of Light and Music were not the peaks of Madonna's career by any stretch of the imagination but they did have a few singles that resonated with her fans and the general public. Her output after that not so much. The Tortured Poets Department and Life of a Showgirl may end being Taylor's Ray of Light and Music.
Metallica. Metallica continues to be a massive stadium draw and now a Sphere headliner, but their albums after the Load and Re-Load era have not resonated the way everything that came before those records did. The people flocking to the Sphere are there for Master of Puppets and Black Album classics, not St. Anger or Hardwired . . . To Self-Destruct deep cuts.
U2. A legacy act with a new album out and the original Sphere headliner that has been in legacy mode since All That You Can’t Leave Behind. They have had a single here or there since that album but again nothing that comes close to their early and mid-career output,
Bands like the Beatles and Nirvana who broke up or otherwise ended early in their careers are immune to this, but I feel safe saying that if either band was putting out records 20 years into their careers that would not be hitting like the White Album, Revolver, Rubber Soul, Nevermind, or even Unplugged in New York.
Phish. Phish is a unique example given their symbiotic relationship with their fanbase. To most Phish fans, their newer material will never touch the output they had in their 1.0 and 2.0 eras. Also, their records were never the point of the band, it has always been about the live shows. Whenever they put out new albums, those songs ultimately get judged by how they jam out the song once the lyrical portion of the composition ends.
Taylor Swift may still hit a home run with a single or two going forward, but the odds that it will land in upper echelon of her discography is minimal. Tom Petty did have Walls on the She's The One soundtrack so a breakthrough single is always possible. If this is inevitable as I posit, my suggestion to fight it would be for Taylor to link up with a killer producer who is responsible for some of the greatest albums put out recently by some of the best songwriters and artists - Shooter Jennings.
What did I miss and where did I err?